Mixed Cookie Box - You pick the flavors!

Pick a box of 6 (that's 6 for the price of 5) or a box of 12 (12 for the price of 9), then tell us which cookies you want - any mix you like.

How it works:

1. Choose your box size from the dropdown above.
2. Add to cart.
3. At checkout, list your flavors in the "special instructions" box — for example: 3 Chocolate Chip, 2 S'Mores, 1 Snickerdoodle.

4. The flavors:

   • Chocolate Chip — the classic, baked the way it's supposed to be: golden edges, soft middle, plenty of chocolate.
   • Snickerdoodle — soft, buttery, and rolled in cinnamon sugar.
   • Cookies n Cream — packed with chocolate sandwich cookie crunch in every bite.
   • The Neptune — our lemon-saltine sugar cookie. Sweet, salty, a little tangy — the one people don't expect and can't stop eating.
   • The Early Bird— soft, chewy maple snickerdoodle - warm cinnamon and rich maple rolled together,  finished with a smooth espresso icing

   *Unsure, or forget to leave a note? You'll get Mikey's Choice — a mix of our favorites from that week's bake.*

   *Ordering more than one box? Just label them in your note: "Box 1: … / Box 2: …"*

   ~ Baked daily in Berlin, Maryland. Shipped nationwide via USPS - baked and on its way within 72 hours, at your door in about 2 days.