Build Your Own Cookie Box

Pick 6 or 12 handmade cookies, any mix you like. Baked fresh in Berlin, Maryland and shipped nationwide. Send a box to someone, or keep them all yourself.

How it works

1. Choose a box of 6 or a box of 12.
2. List your flavors in the special requests box. For example: 3 Chocolate Chip, 2 Snickerdoodle, 1 Neptune.
3. We bake your cookies and mail them the same day. Your box order is processed within 72 hours of your order and shows up about 2 days later.

Not sure what to pick, or forget the note? You'll get Mikey's Choice, a mix of our favorites from that week's bake. 

The cookies

• Chocolate Chip. The classic, baked the way it's supposed to be: golden edges, soft middle, plenty of chocolate.
• Snickerdoodle. Soft, buttery, and rolled in cinnamon sugar.
• Cookies n Cream. Packed with chocolate sandwich cookie crunch in every bite.
• The Neptune. Our lemon-saltine sugar cookie. Sweet, salty, a little tangy. The one people don't expect and can't stop eating.
• The Early Bird. A soft, chewy maple snickerdoodle with warm cinnamon, rich maple, and a smooth espresso icing.

The deal

• Box of 6: $24.50. That's 6 for the price of 5.
• Box of 12: $44.00. That's 12 for the price of 9.

Sending it as a gift?

Put their address in at checkout and write your note in the gift message box. We'll handwrite it and tuck it in. No prices go in the box.

Who's baking

We're a veteran-owned, family-run bakery in Berlin, Maryland. Everything in this box is made by hand, by us, the day it ships.