Thanksgiving Menu 2026

**Pre- Order deadline is Thursday, November 19th!

Call or email to order TODAY!**

Year - Round Menu Items

(Please be advised that our daily menu rotates. If you're looking for a particular item, please call the bakery to check availability or to place an order)

Ordering for shipping? Use the online-order links below for our shipped boxes. For bakery pickup, please email info@mandalapies.com or call 410-713-9219. Online box selections may differ from the daily bakery menu.

  • The Floridian (Key Lime Pie)
  • The Old Farmer's Almanac  (Apple Pie w/ Cinnamon Roll Crust) · Order this item online (shipped pie & cookies box; includes one 1-lb pie and four cookies)
  • No Bad Apple  (Traditional Apple Pie)
  • Peanut butter Chocolate Cream
  • Banana Cloud (Banana Cream)
  • Toasted in Paradise (Coconut Cream) 
  • Farmhouse Quiche (Veggie, Bacon, Bacon, Jalapeno)

 

  • Cookies · Order this item online (shipped Build Your Own Cookie Box, 6 or 12 cookies; see product page for available flavors)
    • Classic Chocolate Chip 
    • The Neptune
    • The Italian Kitchen Sink (Olive Oil, Lemon, Pistachio)
    • S'mores (Chocolate chip, Graham cracker, Home made toasted marshmallow)
    • Snickerdoodle
    • Cookies & Cream 
    • Maple Brown sugar 
    • Peanut Butter Honey
    • Early Bird (Maple Cinnamon Cookie w/Espresso icing)
    • Pumpkin Latte Cookie
    • Not Your Mom's Comfy Sweater (gingersnap/chai)
    • Oatmeal Raisin
    • Fall Feels (chocolate chip & pumpkin cookie w/ pecans & caramel drizzle)

To order for pick up: 

Email: info@mandalapies.com OR  Call: 410-713-9219